Difference Between Mechanical And Hydraulic Disc Brake

SHARE

Mechanical disk brakes

Mechanical disk brakes are component in the automotive and cycling industries that provide reliable and efficient stopping power. These braking systems are widely used in automobile from bicycles to motorcycles and even some smaller automobiles.

Mechanical disk brakes consist of several key components. The primary components include a rotor, caliper, brake pads, and a mechanical actuation mechanism. The rotor, commonly known as the brake disc, is a circular metal disc that is attached to the wheel hub. It rotates along with the wheel and is the surface on which the brake pads make contact to generate stopping force. The caliper is a housing that encloses the brake pads and is mounted on a fixed part of the vehicle’s frame or fork.

The brake pads, typically made of friction material (such as composite materials or organic compounds), are housed within the caliper and are responsible for creating the necessary friction to slow down or stop the vehicle. When the brakes are applied, the mechanical actuation mechanism, which can be a cable or linkage system, engages the brake pads by squeezing them against the spinning rotor. This action generates friction and heat, which, in turn, slows down or stops the vehicle.

Mechanical disk brakes are reliable and consistent in performance. They are less prone to overheating compared to some other braking systems, such as drum brakes, which can experience brake fade under heavy use. Mechanical disk brakes also offer better modulation and control, allowing the operator to adjust the braking force precisely. This feature is especially important in sports and recreational applications, such as mountain biking, where precise control can be a matter of safety.

Maintenance and installation are relatively straightforward with mechanical disk brakes. Unlike hydraulic systems, which require bleeding and fluid management, mechanical brakes use cables that are easier to replace and adjust. This simplicity makes them a popular choice for cyclists and motorcyclists who perform their own maintenance.

Hydraulic disc brakes

Hydraulic disc brakes represent a advancement in braking technology. Hydraulic disc brakes consist of several essential components, including a rotor, caliper, brake pads, hydraulic lines, and a master cylinder. The rotor, also known as the brake disc, is a flat, circular metal disc that is mounted on the wheel hub. It rotates along with the wheel and serves as the surface upon which the brake pads make contact to generate stopping force. The caliper is a housing that contains the brake pads and is mounted on a fixed part of the vehicle’s frame or fork.

The brake pads are positioned inside the caliper and are made from friction materials designed to provide high levels of stopping power and heat resistance. The hydraulic lines connect the master cylinder to the caliper, carrying hydraulic fluid that transmits the force applied at the master cylinder to the brake pads.

The key to the effectiveness of hydraulic disc brakes lies in their hydraulic actuation system. The master cylinder, typically located at the brake lever or pedal, contains a piston that is actuated when the rider or driver applies pressure. This piston pressurizes the hydraulic fluid within the system. The pressure is transmitted instantly through the hydraulic lines to the caliper, where it forces the brake pads against the spinning rotor. The friction generated between the pads and the rotor slows down or stops the vehicle.

Hydraulic disc brakes also require less effort at the brake lever or pedal compared to mechanical brakes. This reduced effort translates to less hand or foot fatigue during extended braking periods, which can be crucial in demanding scenarios such as downhill mountain biking or driving in challenging conditions.

Maintenance for hydraulic disc brakes is generally less frequent than mechanical systems. They are less susceptible to cable stretch and offer self-adjustment as the brake pads wear down, ensuring consistent performance over time. Additionally, hydraulic brakes are less prone to overheating, which can lead to brake fade—a loss of braking power—in demanding situations like downhill descents or heavy loads.

Mechanical vs Hydraulic Disc Brake: Key Differences

FeatureMechanical Disc BrakeHydraulic Disc Brake
Operating PrincipleUses a cable to actuate the brake caliper.Utilizes hydraulic pressure to actuate the brake caliper.
Brake FluidDoes not use any brake fluid.Requires hydraulic brake fluid to operate.
ModulationOffers less precise control over braking power.Provides more precise modulation for better control.
MaintenanceGenerally requires more frequent maintenance, including cable adjustments.Requires less maintenance, primarily fluid checks and occasional bleeding.
Pad Wear AdjustmentRequires manual adjustment of the pads as they wear down.Typically features self-adjusting or automatic pad wear compensation.
Brake FeelTends to have a stiffer and less linear brake feel.Offers a smoother and more linear brake feel.
Installation ComplexityUsually simpler to install and set up.May require more expertise to install due to fluid handling and bleeding.
Heat DissipationLess effective at dissipating heat, making them prone to overheating during prolonged use.More effective at heat dissipation, making them suitable for demanding situations.
WeightTypically lighter due to the absence of hydraulic components.Slightly heavier due to hydraulic components and fluid.
CostGenerally more affordable upfront.Tends to be more expensive due to the added complexity and components.
PerformanceOffers inferior performance, especially in extreme conditions or heavy braking scenarios.Provides superior performance, particularly in demanding situations.
Brake FadeMore prone to brake fade, where braking efficiency decreases with prolonged use.Less susceptible to brake fade, maintaining consistent performance.

Advantages And Disadvantages of Hydraulic Disc Brakes

Advantages

  • More stopping power/ More efficient
  • Less frequent maintenance and adjustment because the brakes self adjust.
  • The system is sealed which keeps contaminants out. This means less cleaning is required.
  • Smoother operation because there is less friction in the system.
  • Better brake modulation/control of the braking force
  • Lighter
  • More consistent
  • Easier on the hands because they require less force to operate
  • You can ride faster because you can stop faster
  • More technologically advanced/ Higher end

Disadvantages

  • More expensive
  • Harder to service in the field because they are more complex. Specialty tools and fluid are required.
  • Spare parts are hard to find in remote regions and some developing countries
  • More difficult to maintain because you have to bleed the brake lines occasionally.

Advantages And Disadvantages Mechanical Disc Brakes

Advantages

  • Cheaper
  • Easier to repair and maintain because they are simpler
  • Replacement parts are easier to find around the world because they use the same cables and levers as rim brakes
  • You can easily service them in the field with basic tools

Disadvantages

  • Less stopping power/ Less efficient
  • They require more frequent adjustments as cables stretch
  • Harder to modulate braking force
  • Friction in the brake lines can make them feel less smooth to operate and less consistent
  • You have to clean them more often because the brake lines can get contaminated with dirt or debris
  • Heavier
  • Slower
  • Harder on the hands because it takes more force to apply the brakes
  • The pads are more likely to rub when they are out of adjustment
  • They are considered lower end and are less technologically advanced.

Key Takeaways

  • A mechanical disc brake uses cables as a braking medium whereas hydraulic disc brake uses the fluid as a braking medium.
  • The mechanical disc brake is heavier in weight as compared to hydraulic disc brake.
  • A mechanical disc brake is less sensitive, requires more force to come to a stop and the hydraulic disc brake is more sensitive and efficient.
  • Maintainance is frequent in mechanical disc brake whereas hydraulic brake is the maintenance free.
  • Adjustment of brakes is easy in mechanical braking while complex in hydraulic braking.
  • The hydraulic disc brake is expensive as compared to mechanical disc brake.
  • Hydraulic brakes give better performance for the same size rotor, but mechanical brakes are good enough if you are using a bigger rotor and set them up correctly.